Spend time talking about Padre Pio, watch part or all of a Padre Pio Movie, and make stigmata gloves. Also, learn about stigmata and what it means to be a mystic.
Buy cheap brown gloves (only need one per person) and some red paint. Cut the fingers off of the gloves and paint a cross with the red paint on the palm and outside of the gloves to represent the blood from the stigmata. Challenge the youth to wear the gloves for a week and when people ask about the gloves to teach them about the stigmata.
The next time you meet, follow up with questions on what is was like to be asked questions, if they couldn’t answer some of the questions, and if they had any new questions they wanted answers to.